caveman-commit (JuliusBrussee/caveman) vs setup-pre-commit (mattpocock/skills)
caveman-commit (JuliusBrussee/caveman)
26.0 / 30
SituationalSafe
caveman-commit: writes Conventional Commits messages with a breaking-change footer (control 4.0, skill 5.0, one-liner 4.95) for about the same tokens; control writes a plain sentence, and a one-sentence prompt of the format does as well
- SOTAPass
setup-pre-commit (mattpocock/skills)
29.0 / 30
RecommendedSafe
setup-pre-commit: for a vague 'add commit hooks' request plain Codex builds a different (native git hook) setup, even calling npm in a pnpm repo (seen in one run); the skill and a one-sentence prompt both give the Husky + lint-staged setup (5.0 vs 1.4)
- SOTAPass