caveman-review (JuliusBrussee/caveman) vs review-animations (emilkowalski/skills)
caveman-review (JuliusBrussee/caveman)
25.1 / 30
SituationalSafe
caveman-review: shifts code reviews toward short per-finding lines (control 3.3, skill 4.2, one-liner 4.8) at the same tokens, but the skill's own L<line> line format was followed in only some runs; a one-sentence prompt of the format scores higher
- SOTAPass
review-animations (emilkowalski/skills)
24.9 / 30
RecommendedSafe
review-animations: makes a pull-request motion review find the planted problems and give exact fixes (control 2.9, skill 4.4, one-liner 4.9) at 1.2x the tokens; a one-sentence prompt of the checklist does better
- SOTAPass